seasonal made-to-order menu
Sweet Pies | Savories | Pastries | packaged goods
All orders must be picked up during the day, during open shop hours.
Pre-ordered pies and pastries can be ordered online below, in person, or over the phone. Feel free to call 614-268-3662 to place an order or ask any questions!
**If pies or pastries are not picked up on the specified day during open hours, and we have not been notified of an issue or delay in the appropriate amount of time, the items will be donated to a local food pantry. No refunds.
Sweet Pies
An innovative twist on the classic southern pecan pie. Made with organic maple syrup and Kentucky Bourbon, with a bottom layer of rich dark chocolate, loaded with pecans, in our flaky butter crust.
10", serves 8–10.
Classic flaky butter pie crust loaded with tart rhubarb and sweet strawberries, topped with a brown sugar oatmeal crumble.
10", serves 8–10.
Everything at Dough Mama is made entirely from scratch, which means every baked good is created by an individual working extremely hard to create the best possible product for you and your loved ones to enjoy! All tips go directly to the team that made your delicious baked goods. We greatly appreciate your appreciation!
A flaky butter pie crust filled with a creamy, tart and sweet lemon custard, sprinkled with floral lavender blossoms.
10", serves 8–10. Sold by the slice or whole.
Double the flaky, buttery crust, filled with chunks of local Idared apples from Branstool Orchards, spiced with cinnamon and freshly ground nutmeg, and sweetened with brown sugar and organic honey.
10", serves 8–10.
A coconut macaroon crust made with almond flour, with a layer of chocolate ganache and coconut pudding, and topped with whipped cream and roasted almonds and coconut flakes. Entirely gluten-free!
10", serves 8–10.
Savory Baked Goods
Six flaky, buttery biscuits laced with cheddar cheese and fresh scallions.
6 per order
Like our sweet pies, our quiches are made from as many locally sourced, seasonal ingredients as possible. Flavors change seasonally as new ingredients become available from local farmers.
We are currently offering a quiche of cheddar, corn, fresh cherry tomatoes, green onion, and dill.
10", serves 6–8.
Sweet Pastries
This vegan cookie is a spicy sweet treat loaded with ginger and rolled in raw sugar. Slightly cruchy on the outside and chewy on the in.
6 per order.
Light, moist, and delicious cakes with hints of almond and loaded with orange zest.
6 per order
Rich and chewy chocolate on chocolate! These cookies are salty and sweet, made with Valrhona cocoa and filled with dark and white chocolate chips. Gluten-free but you would never be able to tell!
Buttery, tender scones filled with grapefruit zest and fresh rosemary, topped with a buttermilk glaze made with the juice of freshly squeezed grapefruits.
Moist, buttery lemon cake with a sweet and tart creamy glaze, you would never know they were gluten - free.
Winner or Columbus Underground's 'Best Desserts' event!
6 per order.
Classic buttery, chocolate chip cookies made with chunks of rich dark chocolate and sprinkled with Maldon sea salt for the perfect balance of salty and sweet.
6 per order
Packaged Goods
Our delicious Tamari Rosemary dressing. Shake it up and put it on your salad use it as a marinade, or drink it out of the jar!
